Sam Hutchinson was once considered a potential successor to John Terry at Chelsea, but a hole in his knee forced the centre-back to retire at 21. Hutchinson then fell into a depression – and despite these setbacks managed to return to professional football.
Sam Hutchinson is a professional soccer player and will be 33 years old on August 3rd. As of now, he is officially unemployed on July 1st, third division club Sheffield Wednesday did not want to extend his contract. These are not exactly ideal circumstances for a professional to continue his career. But for Hutchinson that is no longer decisive.
Twelve years ago, when Hutchinson had just turned 21, it was all over for him. And after it was all over, things got even worse. A so-called chondropathy, which was nothing more than a hole in the cartilage of his right knee, ended Hutchinson’s career before it actually began.
At the age of nine, Hutchinson went to Chelsea’s youth academy in Cobham, where his father Eddie also played. There, the central defender, who can also play as a right-back, went through all the youth teams and finally made his debut with the blues professionals in May 2007 at the age of 17.
Shortly thereafter he received a four-year professional contract, and then-coach Jose Mourinho thought highly of him. Some already saw Hutchinson as John Terry’s successor, and later Carlo Ancelotti became a big fan of his.
Sam Hutchinson: End of career at Chelsea at 21
But in the end it was only three extra games in which Hutchinson was on the field for Chelsea. The problems in my knees got bigger and bigger, the treatments more regular, the setbacks more constant, the downtime longer. Hutchinson’s struggle went on for years.
In August 2010 he thought he had lost it: Hutchinson hung up his football boots. The pain was too great. “Sam will be at the top of his game in anything he does in football, you can see that on his face,” said Terry.
More than six years later, Hutchinson faced the conversation with the Guardians back to his decision at the time: “It wasn’t a big decision because I hated it. I just wanted to end the pain and everything else.”
Sam Hutchinson: His career at a glance
A year and a half later, however, Hutchinson’s world looked different again – but the first six months of it were even worse. Although he continued to have his knee treated, after retiring from football, Hutchinson fell into a depression that was already looming. Suddenly he had to be treated at the same time, physically and mentally.
“I’ve probably done as much mentally as I’ve done physically. You just get to a point in your life where you either just play along and maybe just play a supporting role or you really give it your all,” he said.
Today it has long been clear that Hutchinson really gave everything to pull himself out of this swamp of suffering. “I never wanted to come back. I didn’t want to play for Chelsea anymore because I blamed them, even though it wasn’t theirs,” he said in 2017 about his thoughts immediately after the former end.
Sam Hutchinson and his second ‘debut’ for Chelsea
But after a transplant was placed in his knee and it fully healed, the pain suddenly became a thing of the past. Hutchinson took off his kicking boots and started. Chelsea gave him an 18-month contract.
His rehab wasn’t over yet, but Hutchinson steadily increased the workload. On April 29, 2012, almost two years after his actual career end, caretaker coach Roberto Di Matteo sent him on with nine minutes remaining against Queens Park Rangers – Hutchinson’s side, indeed, made his second “debut” for the Blues alongside Terry.
But nothing more came of this fairytale comeback for Hutchinson at Stamford Bridge. Two loan deals followed, first to Nottingham Forest where he scored straight away in his first game and manager Sean O’Driscoll said of him: “He’s a bit like John Terry.”
Sam Hutchinson becomes a regular at Sheffield Wednesday
However, after an injection to fix a minor problem in his knee, it came back and he missed much of the season. After nine competitive games for the Reds it was over, the following season it went to Chelsea’s farm team Vitesse Arnhem. But football didn’t suit Hutchinson there and he decided to take his career into his own hands.
“That’s exactly what I did at Sheffield Wednesday,” he said of joining the Owls in 2014, admitting he was happier there than before “and started to reap the rewards”. At Hillsborough, Hutchinson advanced to become one of the best players in the Championship as he moved into defensive midfield. If you saw him kick and didn’t know the background, you wouldn’t have guessed that Hutchinson’s knee was no longer normal given his intense and resolute style of play.
In the end, Wednesday played 207 competitive games (eight goals, six assists, five dismissals). His contract was not renewed in 2020, so Hutchinson decided on a six-month adventure in Cyprus at FC Pafos. Sheffield took him back but were relegated to League One in 2021.
New beginning without Hutchinson: Owls fans react indignantly
There he tore off 28 league games last season, in each of which Hutchinson was in the starting XI. However, the re-promotion mission ended in bitter disappointment: a goal in the third minute of added time prevented Wednesday from returning to the 2nd division in the second leg of the promotion play-off against Sunderland.
It was Hutchinson’s last appearance for Sheffield. The club decided to start over, the crowd’s favorite has to look for a new club. The fans reacted indignantly. For coach Darren Moore, the decision against Hutchinson is said to have been the most difficult.
“There’s no reason for me to go,” Hutchinson said five years ago. “This is the only club I’ve actually played for, so it means something to me to be here.” It’s safe to assume he’ll still be getting a few decent offers when he’s almost 33. But this is no longer decisive for Hutchinson.